Miguel de Icaza
quotes Dave Winer, pointing out two patent applications from Apple which
seem intended to grab major chunks of the feed syndication space as
Apple “IP”.
The first application is news feed viewer, 20050289147, filed April 13 2005:
A computer-implemented method for displaying a plurality of articles, the
method comprising: storing a first feed bookmark in a folder, the first feed
bookmark indicating a first feed, the first feed comprising a first plurality
of articles; storing a second feed bookmark in the folder, the second feed
bookmark indicating a second feed, the second feed comprising a second
plurality of articles; aggregating the first feed and the second feed to form
a third feed; and displaying the third feed.
I think there were many RSS readers that implemented this, and others from the
patent application, before April 2005. I know Liferea, the one I use, has
had UI-level aggregation since September 2004, with its
VFolders.
Next, news feed browser, 20050289468, filed April 13 2005. This one contains a wide range of claims, but here’s one that stands out as
particularly trivial:
A computer-implemented method for discovering a feed, the method comprising:
receiving a request to display a file; determining that the file includes
relationship XML; determining that a Uniform Resource Locator (URL) within
the relationship XML indicates a file that comprises the feed; and displaying
one of a group containing the feed and a link to the feed.
That’s pretty much RSS autodiscovery, as described in 2002.
The listed inventors in both patents are: Kahn, Jessica; (San Francisco, CA) ;
Alfke, Jens; (San Jose, CA) ; Wilkin, Sarah Anne; (Menlo Park, CA) ; Howard,
Albert Riley JR.; (Sunnyvale, CA) ; Forstall, Scott James; (Mountain View, CA)
; Lemay, Stephen O.; (San Francisco, CA) ; Melton, Donald Dale; (San Carlos,
CA) ; Loofbourrow, Wayne Russell; (San Jose, CA).
Thanks, Apple! and thanks, “inventors”!
It’s important to note that this is still in the application stage, and as such
can be invalidated, or narrowed down to a saner level, by using the techniques
described here. I strongly
recommend that people working in the syndication field with sufficient
knowledge and expertise who feel strongly enough about this should spend a
little time doing so, before the patent is issued and it becomes a
multi-million-dollar task to invalidate it. (however, IANApatentL of course ;)
Tags: apple, feeds, patent-applications, patents, rss, uspto